"Dedicated to Helping You Find and Evaluate 
the Best Accounting Software Products & Resellers"

Financial Reporting

According to Kieso-Weygandt (a popular intermediate accounting text book that has occupied many a CPA for endless hours), the primary objective of an accounting system is to "summarize transactional data into useful management reports that management can use to manage the business". With that said, the table below summarizes selected financial reporting capabilities for selected products.

  Integrates With FRx Integrates With Crystal Reports Integrates With F9 from Synex Systems Provides Built-In Ratio Reports Provides Built-In Graphical Reports Has Built-in Report Writer Produces Hotlink Data to Spreadsheet Supports Event-Triggered Reporting
For the low-end market
BusinessWorks Gold No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
M.Y.O.B.  No No No Yes Yes Yes No No
One Write Plus No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Peachtree 2000 5.0 No No No No No No No No
Peachtree for Windows 7.0 No No No No No Yes No Yes
Peachtree Complete Accounting
2003
No No No No No Yes No Yes
QuickBooks 2000 No No No Yes Yes Yes No No
QuickBooks Pro 2000 No No No Yes Yes Yes No No
For the middle market
ACCPAC for Windows Series 4.0 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Microsoft Dynamics  Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No
MAS 90 and MAS 200 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Navision Attain (Microsoft) No Yes No Yes No Yes No No
Platinum for Windows by Best Yes Yes Yes No No No No No
Professional Series (ACCPAC) Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes
iScala 2.1 No Yes No Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Solomon IV (Microsoft) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Traverse 8.3 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Visual AccountMate 4.0 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No
For the beginning ERP market
Axapta (Microsoft) No Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
MAS 500 Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes No
eEnterprise 7.0 (Microsoft) Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No
Epicor eFinancials  Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes No Yes
SAP Accelerated Financials R/3 No No No Yes Yes Yes No No
ACCPAC Executive Series  No No Yes No No Yes Yes No
Solomon IV (Microsoft) Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes No


A Brief Discussion of Financial Reporting

A primary objective of any financial accounting system is to provide accurate financial statements on a timely basis. A frequent complaint is that a product won't produce the kind of financial reports a company wants. Yet, considering the importance of financial reporting, users typically fail to fully consider financial reporting capabilities when evaluating products.

When it comes to financial reporting, many accounting software products incorporate two third-party products—FRx and Crystal Reports—into their packages rather than develop their own. And in recent years those two products have become industry standards. Both work seamlessly with more than 25 top accounting software packages. So dominant is Microsoft's FRx that some products, such as Great Plains Dynamics, Platinum for Windows by Best and Solomon IV, rely on it as their primary financial reporting tool. 

When evaluating software, you should ask whether it works with FRx or, if it doesn't, whether the built-in module exhibits comparable features. Here are some of the key capabilities of FRx: 

  • Produces financial statements with up to 256 columns.
  • Links financial data from either a general ledger or other products such as a spreadsheet or database application.
  • Creates calculations such as expenses divided by units produced.
  • Produces provisional financial statements—that is, as if all un-posted transactions have been posted.
  • Views reports on screen and easily drills down from financial summary information into account and transaction details.
  • Sends e-mail reports directly to remote users from the report preview screen.
  • Exports and imports reports to and from spreadsheets.
  • Handles complex calculations such as conditional if-then statements.
  • Provides a drag-and-drop utility in the reporting tree so users can see the financial effect of restructuring.
  • Creates virtual roll-up structures for reporting at different levels—that is, by store, city, state, territory or country.
  • Prepares and distributes presentation-quality reports using customized fonts, colors and other formatting options.
  • Compares revenue and expense figures for different departments by creating side-by-side reports.
  • Operates in a client-server environment.

As powerful as it is, FRx primarily offers superior reporting capabilities only from the general ledger module; it's not designed to extract data easily from other modules. This is Crystal Reports' forte. It's superb at extracting and reporting transactions from all modules. For example, it can produce a set of mailing labels for all vendors that received more than $600 for the year but failed to provide the proper taxpayer identification number. It also can produce a report for each salesperson, displaying his or her top 10 customers in terms of total sales, the outstanding amounts receivable and the profit margin attributed to each customer. Like FRx, Crystal Reports works with many of the top accounting software packages. Some products such as MAS 90 and MAS 500 have even gone so far as to use Crystal Reports to develop all its module reports.

Over the years, I have encountered many clients who thought they had to replace their accounting software because of inadequate financial reporting. A number of them, however, resolved that problem simply by adding FRx and Crystal Reports.

Rating Ratios

Another important aspect of financial reporting is built-in ratio reporting. Unfortunately, most accounting software and third-party application developers either ignore this function or don't give it the attention it deserves. Many vendors say they provide built-in ratio reporting, however, in my view, the number of ratios most of them provide is hardly adequate.

One of the few products that does adequately addresses this need is BusinessWorks Gold—a product that serves the low-end market. Each of its modules contains a flash report function that summarizes key financial ratios and highlights key information. The general ledger flash report displays 20 key ratios for the following periods: current, year-to-date and prior-year. Also displayed are sales histories and balance sheet amounts for the past 24 months. The inventory flash report provides, among other things, inventory ratios, days in inventory, a reconciliation of the inventory account for the month, inventory and cost-of-goods-sold balances as well as highlights of the fastest selling and highest profit items. This is vital information that helps management detect problems in time to take corrective measures. In any company, it's important for management to receive a set of financial statements at least monthly, complete with financial ratio reports attached. 

Graphics

A picture is indeed worth a thousand words, but it's probably worth several thousand numbers. You should check to be sure the package you're considering can convert numbers into graphics. Several accounting packages can produce pie, line and area charts from the numerical data. 

Pivot Tables

One of the most powerful analytical tools are pivot tables—a tool used in spreadsheets that allows the user to take data and pivot, or turn, it in many different ways so the information can viewed from different perspectives. For example, it can show the relationship between, say, sales in various cities and sales of individual products; and then, by pivoting the data, it can compare sales broken down by cities with those by individual outlets or by individual salespeople.

Many companies praise pivot tables; for example, Microsoft claims the pivot table is its primary vehicle for analyzing financial data. 

ACCPAC for Windows offers an excellent reporting tool called BrioQuery, which is basically a pivot table function. This tool queries the ACCPAC database using virtually any criteria desired. The resulting query may then be displayed as raw numbers, charts or in a conventional spreadsheet pivot table format. Other accounting packages allow the user to export data into Excel, which has its own pivot table features, but ACCPAC's pivot tool is much faster and easier to use.

Hotlinking

Another important financial report feature is the ability to hotlink accounting data directly to an Excel or Lotus 1-2-3 spreadsheet—a feature first found in Platinum for Windows. Such a feature allows the user to export financial statements directly to Lotus or Excel as easily as sending the report to a printer. Once in Lotus or Excel, Platinum for Windows automatically inserts the @SUM formulas everywhere, making what-if scenarios a snap to create.

Event Triggered Reporting (Alarms)

Many accounting software products have the ability to alert users to predefined financial conditions. With such a feature a CFO can create simple calculations that the accounting software continuously compares against a preset value. When that value is exceeded, an alert pops on the computer screen. For example, a CFO might create calculations to sound an alert if cash on hand falls below $100,000, gross margin drops below 20% or the number of days in inventory exceeds 80. In most cases, there is no limit to the number of triggers that can be established.

ACCPAC ProSeries, for example, not only monitors custom events, but it can alert mangers by sending them e-mails. As you would expect, many high-end accounting products—the so-called beginning enterprise resource planning (ERP) products, such as Epicor eFinancials, offer event-triggered reporting. However, this high-end feature also can be found in an entry-level product, Peachtree Complete Accounting. Its alarms automatically monitor amounts related to account balances, customers, vendors and employees.

For accounting software packages that don't provide event-triggered alarms, a third-party solution often is available. For example, Forest & Trees (from Computer Associates) can extract data from a host of accounting software packages, spreadsheets and other databases. In addition, the software can dial your telephone or beeper if it spots a potential problem. Thus, it can warn of impending problems on a real-time basis, whether you're in a meeting, traveling or on the golf course. Although Forest & Trees can provide alerts, it is difficult to program so you should probably hired a consultant to install and set it up.

Copyright © 1999-2003 Accounting Software Advisor, LLC.
All rights reserved 
No part of this web site may be used for commercial purposes of any kind without our express written consent.

______________

 

Read our Mission Statement
Read our Disclosure Statement
Read our Disclaimer Statement

Contact the Editor - J. Carlton Collins, CPA

 

__________________

 

Click Here If You Need Help
 We can help you as little, or as much, as you need